So far there have been four presidential impeachments throughout all of US history, and now Trump makes up half of those, I guess that could also be used as a good fat joke. It’s quite unreal when you think of it in that sort of terms, and the fact Trump is the only US President to have been impeached twice. Only two other US presidents have been impeached, Bill Clinton and Andrew Johnson and another was close to being impeached but resigned before it took place – Richard Nixon.
So far no US Presidents have ever been convicted by the Senate and removed from office after these impeachments and it is likely to remain that way even after the latest Senate trial on Donald Trump is completed. This is largely due to needing a special majority of two-thirds in the Senate to convict and remove the President from office, neither of which either side typically ever has. Meanwhile impeachments only require a simple majority in the House of Representatives.
With that being said let’s look into all of the presidential impeachments in US history so far, starting with the first ever impeachment of a US President – Andrew Johnson. We shall also look into the resignation of Richard Nixon at the end.
The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson
Andrew Johnson was the 17th President of the United States he was a Democratic Party member. He served a term of four-years from April 15th 1865 until March 4th 1869, he was Vice-President to Abraham Lincoln running on the ticket of the National Union party (a party of Abraham Lincoln made up of the Republicans and elements of other parties to show unity during the American Civil War) but assumed the presidency after Lincoln was assassinated after the end of the American Civil War. Andrew Johnson returned as a member of the Democratic Party.
One of the things Andrew Johnson was best known for during his time as President was the Alaska Purchase, when the US acquired the Alaskan territory from the Russian Empire, which would not become a US state until almost 100-years had passed, the territory gained statehood in 1959, the same year as Hawaii did. Another big part of Andrew Johnson’s time as President was restoration and reconstruction after the American Civil War, and the controversial way Andrew Johnson tried to deal with these challenges lead him into conflict with the Republicans, who dominated Congress at the time.
Andrew Johnson wanted to restore seceded states back to the Union as fast as possible and as such he put out a series of proclamations that directed seceded states to hold conventions and elections to reform their civil governments. Many of the Southern States in this decided to return their old leaders and passed racist Black Code laws that degraded former black slaves of many civil liberties. This outraged Congressional Republicans who refused to seat such legislators and also advanced their own legislation to overrule such actions of the Southern States.
Unfortunately the Congressional Republicans in doing this would face vetoes on their legislation from Andrew Johnson, leading to a back-and-forth contest of presidential vetoes and congressional overriding of such vetoes. Andrew Johnson also opposed the 14th Amendment which gave citizenship to former slaves. As the political skirmish between Andrew Johnson and Congress escalated the President decided to unexpectedly go on a national tour to try and turn public opinion against the Republican-dominated Congress by promoting his own controversial executive policies, this was in hopes of getting the Republican Congress to back-down. Many of the Presidents speeches proved politically disastrous and self-damaging, further on he also suffered political embarrasment when his home state of Tennessee became one of the only Southern States at the time to ratify the 14th Amendment.
After Andrew Johnson said he planned to fire anyone in his Cabinet who disagreed with him, due to entrenched opposition against his Southern policies, Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act to restrict the ability for the President to simply just fire his Secretaries and would instead require approval from the Senate. The bill was vetoed by Johnson but Congress overode the veto and it became law. This Act would eventually lead to the impeachment of Andrew Johnson.
Several attempts were made to bring forth impeachment charges in 1867 by the House Committee of the Judiciary such as by exaining Johnson’s bank accounts, summoning Cabinet members to testify and they investigated whether the President may have impeded the prosecution of the former Confederate President Davis after he was released on bail. Impeachment charges were for now voted down after little of significance was found.
Tensions between Johnson and Stanton continued building meanwhile as they both attempted to out-manuver each other related to Johnson’s Southern policies. One such sticking point was whether military officers placed in command of the South could override civil authorities. Some time after this Congress recovened and passed a Reconstruction Act that clarified this question against the President, who vetoed it but it was overriden. The bill also restricted the President’s control over the Army in the South.
It was after this point, when Congress had gone into recess, that the President decided he was going to fire Stanton after all and he eventually demanded the resignation of Stanton, but Stanton refused to do so with Congress out of session, so instead the President suspended him pending the next meeting of Congress, which the Tenure of Office Act allowed.
The General of the Army Ulysses S. Grant, another strong opponent of the President who had worked alongside Stanton to undermine Johnson’s Southern policy, was placed in Stanton’s place as a temporary replacement, he made Grant transfer several high-ranking army officers who had angered him over following Congress’ plan. Johnson also issued a proclamation that pardoned most Confederates, except for those who held office under the Confederacy or who had held federal office but broken their oaths. This move further angered the Republicans, but they were cowed after the Democrats found some success in the Ohio legislature elections and after Ohio, Connecticut and Minnesota turned down propositions that would give African-Americans the right to vote.
But it wasn’t long until attempts at impeachment resumed when Congress met in November, the Judiciary Committee this time passed a resolution of impeachment, but it would be another failed attempt and voted down by the House. Johnson would soon after this notify Congress of Stanton’s suspension and Grant’s interim position. The Senate ultimately disaproved and as such Stanton remained, Johnson though still attempted to dismiss and replace him, but Stanton refused to leave his office and this time the House impeached Johnson for intentionally violating the Tenure of Office Act, there were 11 articles of impeachment in total that were related to violation of the Tenure of Office and questioning legitimacy of Congress.
A subsequent Senate trial saw him very nearly convicted on the 11th article of impeachment over violation of the Tenure of Office, off by just one vote of the two-thirds majority needed, votes on whether to convict over two further articles of impeachment yielded frustratingly identical results, after this Johnson’s opponents abandoned their attempt to convict Johnson. Johnson nonetheless did not serve a second term as he failed to get re-nominated in his party again. Ulysses S. Grant went on to win the next presidential election as a Republican.
The Tenure of Office Act was later repealed in 1887, which I’m sure was a massive relief for Donald Trump, whose administration has had one of the highest turnover rates of any other.
The Impeachment of Bill Clinton
William Jefferson Clinton, known popularly as Bill Clinton, was the 42nd President of the United States serving two full terms from 1993 until 2001. He has since perhaps become one of the most polarising figures in modern US politics up until Donald Trump made his appearance, and those in the Clinton family who have entered into US political offices have collectively been dubbed the Clinton Dynasty/Cabal etc. There are many conspiracy theories and vast allegations that circulate around the Clinton family now, specifically Bill and Hillary Clinton, many of them likely far blown out of proportion and without substance that’d hold up in a court of law. Many opponents of the Clintons who believe in such allegations and conspiracies will often refer to them collectively as the Clinton crime family.
Bill Clinton is a member of the Democratic Party and before becoming President served as Governor of Arkansas several times and Attorney-General of Arkansas. His wife Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State under the Barack Obama administration and has attempted to run for president on two seperate occasions. In becoming President Bill Clinton turned Geogre H.W Bush into a one-term president.
Some of the things that Bill Clinton was known for during his presidency was the North American Free Trade Agreement, Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act, reforms to welfare, and the appointments of Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer to the United States Supreme Court. Clinton also ordered military intervention into the Bosnian and Kosovo wars and also signed the Dayton Agreement which paved the way for peace in Bosnia & Herzegovina. Clinton also signed the Iraq Liberation Act to support non-military efforts of toppling Saddam Hussein from power.
Clinton would become the 2nd US President to be impeached by the House of Representatives. They were charges of perjury to a grand jury and obstruction of justice related to the Clinton v. Jones case which led to the revelation of the Monica Lewinsky affair scandal. He was acquitted by the Senate and the impeachment may well have served to bolster the approval rating of Bill Clinton, this effect had made some democrats wary of impeaching Trump during his first term, as it could have had a similar effect and allow him to more easily win a 2nd term, but these fears were never realized.
The first article of impeachment was to do with perjury to a grand jury, which means Bill Clinton was accused of lying under oath to a grand jury, which is a federal offense. The offense took place in relation to the landmark 1997 SCOTUS case of Clinton v. Jones, which was a case that argued the sitting US President does not have immunity from civil law litigation in a federal court over acts that were done before taking office and which are unrelated to the office – relating to a sexual harassment case against Bill Clinton alledged to have taken place while he was Governor of Arkansas, which was delayed due to Bill Clinton becoming President. The SCOTUS ultimately ruled in favour of Jones.
A grand jury had been convened related to the case to investigate perjury he may have made during the case in his sworn deposition, this lead to the Monica Lewinsky scandal being uncovered after tapes had emerged in the SCOTUS case, this also famously led to Clinton saying in an interview “I did not have sexual relations with that woman.”
Monica Lewinsky was a 22-year-old White House Intern who later worked in the Department of Defense, the Clinton v. Jones case had led to the revelation of their affair from 1995 until 1997 while he was in office as President. Due to the lie under oath and attempts to conceal the affair a 2nd impeachment article was passed for obstruction of justice in relation to that. The articles of impeachment were heavily voted through by Republicans although some democrats also voted on side.
The Senate later held a 21-day long trial on the charges, both leading to acquittals with both parties voting more-or-less down usual lines.
The Double Impeachment of Donald Trump
The two most recent impeachments happened in December 2019 and January 2021 respectively, making Donald Trump the only President in US history to be impeached twice. Donald Trump was the 45th President of the United States and is one of the most controversial presidents in US history and a deeply polarising figure. He ran for President as part of the Republican Party and developed a new sort of populist movement among party supporters known as Trumpism.
He was known for many things during his 4-years in office from 2016 until 2021, including starting construction of a border wall between the US and Mexico; attempting to end Obamacare; a muslim travel ban between the US and several muslim-majority countries and its ensuing court battles; the attempted ending of the DACA program to give citizenship to undocumented migrants who had been brought over by their parents as children – and its ensuing court battles; the appointment of three SCOTUS Justices, two of which were under controversial circumstances; controversial leaving of the Paris Climate Accord and Iran Nuclear Deal; attempted peace process between North and South Korea; and much more.
After his 2016 win accusations would begin coming up over possible Russian interference in the 2016 election in favour of Donald Trump which ended up going as far as accusations of active collusion between Donald Trump, members of his administration and Russia. This led to investigations by the FBI into certain Trump administration figures, such as Micheal Flynn – in one instance Donald Trump had urged then FBI Director James Comey to let Flynn go because he was a “good guy”, Trump would also later fire James Comey, both events led to accusations of obstruction of justice, but no impeachment attempts were succesful due to Republican’s controlling the House at the time.
As the Trump-Russia-Collusion and obstruction of justice accusations further broadened a Special Counsel was eventually set up in May 2017 by then Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein to investigate both accusations led by Robert Mueller. The investigation was massive in scope and involved numerous figures in the Trump administration and others outside of it as well, including a number of companies. The Special Counsel lasted until March 2019, Democrats had gained control of the House in the 2018 Midterm elections but widely held off pursuing any possible attempts at impeachment until after the investigation concluded.
The Muellar Report concluded that the Trump campaign had welcomed Russian interference and also expected to benefit from it, but that there was not enough evidence to bring conspiracy charges against Trump or his associates. The report also was unable to come to a conclusion on obstruction of justice due to a Justice Department guideline that prohibited federal indictment of a sitting President. Both sides saw the report as a win in some way or another, for those on the Democratic side or those opposed to Trump it was vindication enough for his impeachment and removal, while for Republicans and other Trump supporters it proved to them that it was in-fact all a witch hunt after all, as Trump had called it. The investigation is nonetheless credited with bringing charges against 34 individuals, 3 companies and which so far produced 8 guilty pleas and a trial conviction, and it also led to numerous spin-off investigations against Donald Trump and others, a number of which are still ongoing.
The Mueller Report would bring on side numerous more Democrats who were originally divided over impeachment, but such attempts at impeachment were still avoided as a number of senior Democrats didn’t want to potentially make Trump a martyr before the 2020 election.
Eventually though impeachment charges would be brought over after a whistleblower filed a complaint about a phone call between Donald Trump and the President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky that took place on July 25th 2019. It came about that Trump had pressured the Ukrainian President to investigate Crowdstrike, a cybertechnology company that Trump and his supporters accussed of having played a role of alledgedly fabricating the Russia DNC hack as a way to discredit Trump’s 2016 win and that a DNC server was hidden in Ukraine by them, and also to investigate Joe Biden (at the time a presidential candidate for 2020) and his son Hunter Biden over alledged payments to Russia also a part of discrediting Trump. It was said that the White House attempted to cover-up the incident and the whistleblower alledged it may have been part of a wider campaign that included withholding financial aid to the country – Trump would later confirm he had withheld military aid, although under contradictory circumstances.
After these revelations House Speaker Nancy Pelosi would begin an impeachment inquiry into the affair, with the investigation being if whether Trump had solicited foreign inteference into the 2020 US election, of which Trump was then accussed of obstructing the house inquiry itself via telling officials in his administration to ignore subpoenas for documents and testimonies. After the conclusion of the inquiry two articles of impeachment were drawn up, one for abuse of power related to the Ukraine phone call scandal, and Obstruction of Congress for inteference in the house inquiry, both articles were passed and Trump was impeached for the first time. All Republicans and three Democrats had voted against the articles of impeachment.
The Senate trial heavily went down party lines as well, and with Republicans having control of the Senate they were able to vote down attempts to introduce subpoenas, votes on conviction went heavily down party lines, with Mitt Romney being the only Republican senator to vote against Trump on the Abuse of Power charge, this also made him the first ever Senator to vote to convict a President of his own party.
The second impeachment would come in January of 2021 after the 2020 election had seen to Trump’s defeat, followed by numerous failed attempts to overturn the election via court battles that alledged vote fraud in several close states. After these failures protests were organised in Washington D.C for January 6th, backed by Donald Trump and others involved in Trump Campaign lawsuits in the 2020 Election such as Rudy Guliani. The mass protests started with a firey speech from Trump in the city before marching down to the US Capitol buildings – where at the same time Congress was making the final count and certification of the 2020 Electoral College vote to fully certify Joe Biden’s win, where several attempts were made by Republican’s to challenge the results.
It was from this point that things started getting ugly as police and security forces were overwhelmed by the massive crowd who then went on to storm the US Capitol, the Electoral College certification had to be postponed and legislators evacuated. The rioters broke into numerous congressional offices and the Senate floor itself and occupied the Capitol until Trump had finally urged them to disperse and mass reinforcements of police, SWAT and National Guard begun arriving, with Donald Trump having refused to authorize the National Guard, Mike Pence, the Vice-President had done so instead. In the end five people had been killed and people begun calling it an attempt at insurrection abetted by dangerous language used by Trump in the lead up to January 6th and during the day itself – where he had also called on Mike Pence, his Vice-President, to effectively challenge the Electoral College result himself, of which he refused to do.
After this event the House led by Speaker Nancy Pelosi urged Trump’s Cabinet to remove Trump via the 25th Amendment, saying he was no longer fit for office, but after Mike Pence refused to do this the House very quickly drew up an article of impeachment that accused Trump of inciting an insurrection against the US Government, and was then promptly impeached for a 2nd time, with 10 Republican congressman also voting for it, making it the most members of a party ever to vote impeachment on a president of their own party. A Senate trial on this is set to go forth after Trump has already left office, but it will still be possible to convict him nonetheless and also bar him from running in the future, but it is again seen as unlikely that enough Republican’s will come over to convict him.
The Resignation of Richard Nixon – Related to Impeachment & Removal Dangers
Richard Nixon was the 37th US President serving a full term and only a small part of his 2nd term (1969-1974) before he became the first ever US President and so far the only US President to resign from office due to the Watergate Scandal and the likely chance of him being impeached by the House and then removed from office due to Senate conviction. He was a member of the Republican Party. Before becoming President he had been a US Representative and Senator for California and Vice-President to Dwight D. Eisenhower. Nixon had attempted to run for the Presidency previously in 1960 but lost narrowly to Democrat John F. Kennedy. He also almost became Governor of California in another close race.
Richard Nixon was another of the Cold War era US President’s making many of his decisions and activities during that time significant to world events. Major parts of his presidency included ending involvement in the Vietnam War; establishing diplomatic relations with China and calming tensions with the Soviet Union; and the establishment of the Environmental Protection Agency. Nixon also begun the so-called War on Cancer and presided over the Apollo 11 moon landing to win the Space Race. Nixon was re-elected in an electoral landslide for a 2nd term but was taken down by the Watergate Scandal not long afterwards.
The Watergate Scandal is one of the largest and well known political scandals in US history and is the origination of putting -gate on the end of other scandals not just in the US but elsewhere in the world as well. The scandal surfaced after 1972 and related to the Nixon administrations numerous attempts to cover-up a break-in that took place on June 17th, 1972 at the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate Office building in Washington D.C. Five perpatrators involved in the break-in were arrested and the Justice Department managed to connect cash found on them to the Nixon re-election campaign committee.
This damning finding led to further investigations, that uncovered further damning evidence that then led to the House granting its judiciary committee increased investigational authority and the Senate also created a special investigative committee. From this time witnesses would bring forth further damaging testimony about the president Nixon approving plans for a cover-up and that further damning evidence could be found on voice-activated tape recorders in the Oval Office.
The administration of Nixon throughout tried its hardest to resist the investigations and probes which led to a constitutional crisis forming, and continued evidence and testimony against the Nixon administration led to the House commencing the process for impeachment in 1973. Most damaging of all was when the US Supreme Court ordered the release of the Oval Office tapes that revealed Nixon had taken a direct part in the cover-up conspiracy. Articles of impeachment were drawn up by the House for obstruction of justice, abuse of power and contempt of Congress. And so facing almost certain impeachment, a cover-up that was now public and plummeting political support, Nixon resigned on August 9th, 1974. There is strong belief that if he had not he would have been both impeached and convicted and as such removed from office.
The investigations themselves led to 69 indictments and 48 convictions, many of whom were Nixon administration officials. Nixon’s Vice-President, Gerald Ford, replaced him as President after his resignation and pardoned Richard Nixon. Gerald Ford served out the rest of the term and ran for re-election beating Reagan in the primaries but losing to Democrat Jimmy Carter in the election itself – Gerald Ford’s term was the shortest of any US President in history who did not die in office.
Well that gives a nice fun little overview of all the impeachments in US history so far and also an overview of the Nixon Watergate Scandal resignation. I wonder who the next one will be… if history tells us anything it should be a long while yet before another happens.
Thank you for reading this post, if you have any queries please Email me, you can find my Email in the Contacts & Community section. Please also follow The Weekly Rambler on Twitter, Reddit, Pinterest and Facebook which you can access through the buttons at the bottom of this website. You can also use the social media buttons under each blogpost to share with your family, friends and associates. You can also subscribe to Email notifications at the right-side of this website to know whenever a new post goes up (you can easily unsubscribe from this at any time through a button in each Email notification), or alternatively you can use an RSS Feed Reader. Please also join my FB Group The Weekly Ramblers Readers Group where readers can more easily talk with each other and also with me whenever I am on, you can also find it in Community.